Common ICSI errors
On this page you will learn
- a simple way to group ICSI errors so you can find their cause
- the errors that harm oocytes most often
- the errors that cause fertilisation failure
- how your logbook and laboratory indicators help you improve
Why a page on errors
Every embryologist makes errors while learning ICSI. What matters is that they are made under supervision, recognised, recorded and not repeated. This page gathers the errors mentioned on pages 28 to 33 into five groups. When something goes wrong, work through the groups in order: the cause is often earlier than the moment you noticed it.
1. Set-up and environment
- Stage temperature not checked in a drop; oocytes cooled.
- Dish out of the incubator too long, so buffered medium drifts or culture medium loses its gas balance.
- Drops not covered fully by oil, so they evaporate and become concentrated.
- Wrong dish, wrong label, or dish identity not witnessed.
2. Tools
- Pipettes not horizontal, or not in the same focal plane (page 29).
- Air bubble in the injection line, so the meniscus drifts and control is delayed.
- Chipped, blunt or blocked injection pipette used for "just one more".
- Pipettes not changed between patients.
3. Sperm
- Immobilisation too light: membrane intact, risk of failed activation.
- Immobilisation too hard or too close to the head: sperm damaged or stuck.
- Too much PVP drawn up and injected.
- Sperm lost in the pipette, or a second sperm drawn up by mistake. If you are not sure that exactly one sperm is in the pipette, do not inject; expel and start again.
4. Oocyte
- Polar body not positioned at 12 or 6 o'clock, so the pipette passes near the spindle.
- Oolemma not broken before delivery, so the sperm sits in a pocket of membrane.
- Excessive aspiration of ooplasm to break an elastic membrane.
- Holding suction too strong, distorting the oocyte.
- Pipette withdrawn too fast, so ooplasm leaks out with it.
- Injected and uninjected oocytes mixed in the same area of the drop.
5. Records and process
- Injection time not recorded, so the fertilisation check cannot be timed (page 33).
- Membrane behaviour and unusual events not recorded (page 32).
- Pipette and medium lot numbers missing.
- A problem noticed but not reported to the supervisor.
Recognising the pattern
Patterns tell you where to look. Many degenerated oocytes after injection point to group 2 or group 4: tool angle, suction or withdrawal. Good-looking oocytes that do not fertilise, with sperm visible inside, point to group 3: immobilisation and delivery. A whole day of poor results across several operators points to group 1: temperature, pH, media or the incubator (pages 17 and 20). A single operator's results that differ from colleagues' point to technique, and the remedy is supervised practice, not blame.
How the laboratory measures it
The Vienna consensus on ART laboratory KPIs (2017) lists indicators for ICSI, including the normal fertilisation rate after ICSI and the ICSI damage rate, with competency and benchmark values. Your laboratory tracks these per operator over time (page 20). As a trainee you will be compared with the laboratory's own values, not with anyone outside it.
At the bench: your error log
- After every practice or supervised session, write in your logbook (page 61) what you did, how many oocytes, and every difficulty.
- For each difficulty, name the group (1 to 5) and the likely cause.
- Agree one correction with your trainer before the next session.
- Note whether the correction worked.
Errors that put a patient's gametes at risk, such as a possible identity mix-up, are reported to the senior embryologist immediately and handled under the laboratory's incident procedure, whatever the time of day.
Common errors in learning
- Hiding a mistake instead of reporting it.
- Rushing to increase speed before the movement is correct.
- Changing several things at once, so you cannot tell which helped.
Check yourself
- Name the five groups of ICSI errors.
- Many oocytes degenerate after your injections. Which groups do you check first, and why?
- What should you do if you are not sure that exactly one sperm is in the pipette?
- Which two Vienna consensus indicators relate directly to ICSI?
Questions on this page
Will I be judged on my mistakes during training?
You are judged on whether you recognise, record and correct them under supervision. Hiding a mistake is the one error that is never acceptable.
What is the ICSI damage rate?
The share of injected oocytes that degenerate after injection. The Vienna consensus lists it as a laboratory indicator, and it is tracked per operator over time.
What is the first thing to check if a whole day's results are poor?
The environment: stage and incubator temperature, gas and pH, media and oil. A problem affecting every operator usually lies there rather than in one person's technique.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
