Daily QC and lab KPIs (Vienna consensus)
On this page you will learn
- What is checked every day in an IVF laboratory, and how
- The difference between quality control, quality assurance and key performance indicators
- What the Vienna consensus on ART laboratory KPIs (2017) is and how laboratories use it
- How to respond when a reading or an indicator goes out of range
Three ideas, one aim
- Quality control (QC) is checking that equipment and materials are within range today: is the incubator at the right temperature, is the gas correct?
- Quality assurance (QA) is the whole system that makes good work likely: protocols, training, records, audits and corrective actions.
- Key performance indicators (KPIs) are measures of the laboratory's results over time, such as how often injected oocytes fertilise normally. They show whether the system is working.
All three serve one aim: every patient's gametes and embryos get the same reliable care, every day.
The daily checks
Each morning, before any patient work, the laboratory records a set of readings. Typical checks include:
- Incubator temperature, measured with a calibrated thermometer or probe, not only read from the display.
- Incubator carbon dioxide, measured with an independent gas analyser, and oxygen in reduced-oxygen incubators.
- pH of culture medium, measured at intervals with a blood-gas analyser or pH meter, to confirm the gas setting gives the right pH.
- Heated stages, warm blocks and workstation surfaces, measured at the point where the dish sits.
- Gas cylinder pressures and the automatic change-over, so supply never runs out overnight.
- Refrigerator temperatures for media, and room temperature and humidity.
- Liquid nitrogen levels in storage tanks and the oxygen alarm in the cryo area (page 48).
- Alarm and back-up systems, tested at the interval your protocol sets.
Every reading is written in the log with the time and your initials. A reading out of range is acted on before any work in that equipment, and the action is recorded.
The Vienna consensus
In 2017, ESHRE and Alpha (Scientists in Reproductive Medicine) published the Vienna consensus on ART laboratory performance indicators. It sets out a group of indicators that cover the main steps of laboratory work, for example: the proportion of oocytes damaged by ICSI, normal fertilisation after ICSI and after conventional IVF, cleavage on Day 2, blastocyst development, survival of embryos after warming, and implantation. For each indicator it suggests a "competency" value, which every laboratory should reach, and a "benchmark" level, which is an aspirational target.
It also separates reference indicators (such as the proportion of mature oocytes at pick-up, which depends on the clinic as well as the laboratory), performance indicators (which mainly reflect laboratory work) and outcome indicators. This helps you work out where a problem truly lies.
Using KPIs well
- Compare like with like: the patient mix affects many indicators.
- Look at trends over months, not single bad days.
- Track indicators per operator as well, so that a trainee's ICSI or vitrification results are followed during supervised practice (page 61).
- Use KPIs to find problems early, never to make claims to patients.
At the bench
- Arrive in time to complete the QC checks before the first case.
- Measure; do not copy yesterday's number. Write the actual reading.
- If a reading is out of range, repeat it once with care. If still out, inform the senior embryologist, move dishes to a back-up if needed and record what you did.
- Enter outcomes for each case (fertilisation, development, cryo) on the day, so KPI data are complete.
- Take part in the monthly KPI review and ask how your own work compares with the laboratory's competency values.
Quality systems are also expected under the ART (Regulation) Act 2021 and the ICMR national ART guidelines, so the records you keep are part of the laboratory's legal duty, not only good habit.
Common errors
- Copying the previous day's reading into the log
- Trusting the incubator display instead of an independent measurement
- Reacting to one bad day as if it were a trend, or ignoring a slow drift
- Blaming the laboratory for an indicator that mainly reflects the patient group
Check yourself
- What is the difference between quality control and quality assurance?
- Name five readings taken before patient work begins each morning.
- What is the difference between a competency value and a benchmark value in the Vienna consensus?
- Why is the proportion of mature oocytes a reference indicator and not a pure laboratory performance indicator?
Questions on this page
Are KPIs figures to show patients?
No. KPIs measure how well each step of laboratory work is done, so problems can be found and fixed. They are internal quality tools.
What if a QC reading is out of range?
Repeat it carefully, inform the senior embryologist, protect the dishes and record the reading, the cause and the action taken.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
