IVF or ICSI: indications
On this page you will learn
- what conventional insemination and ICSI each ask of the sperm and the oocyte
- the accepted indications for ICSI
- where routine ICSI has not been shown to help
- how the laboratory contributes to the decision on the day
Two ways to bring sperm and oocyte together
In conventional insemination (page 24), each cumulus-oocyte complex is placed with a prepared suspension of motile sperm. The sperm must pass through the cumulus, bind to the zona, undergo the acrosome reaction, penetrate the zona and fuse with the oolemma. Much natural selection is left in place.
In ICSI, one sperm chosen by the embryologist is injected directly into the ooplasm of a mature oocyte (pages 30 and 31). The sperm does not need to swim far, bind or penetrate. This is why ICSI works when sperm are few or cannot fertilise on their own. It is also why ICSI is more invasive, needs denuded mature oocytes, and depends heavily on the skill of the operator.
Accepted indications for ICSI
- Male factor: severely reduced concentration, motility or morphology, so that too few motile sperm are available after preparation for conventional insemination. The thresholds are set by your clinic protocol and judged on the prepared sample, not only on the diagnostic semen analysis.
- Surgically retrieved sperm: sperm from the epididymis or testis (page 54).
- Previous fertilisation failure or very low fertilisation with conventional insemination.
- Limited frozen sperm: few straws available, for example after sperm banking before cancer treatment.
- Vitrified-warmed oocytes (page 50): the zona can harden after vitrification, so these oocytes are normally inseminated by ICSI.
- Preimplantation genetic testing (page 58): ICSI avoids extra sperm stuck to the zona contaminating the biopsy sample.
- In-vitro matured oocytes (page 59).
- Antisperm antibodies in some situations, as decided by the clinician.
Where routine ICSI has not been shown to help
When the semen is normal, for example in unexplained infertility or tubal factor, good studies have not shown that ICSI for everyone gives more live births than conventional insemination. ICSI also adds cost, handling and dependence on operator skill. Professional guidance therefore supports conventional insemination when the semen is adequate, keeping ICSI for the indications above. In some couples a clinician may plan a split, with sibling oocytes inseminated by each method.
Genetic counselling
ICSI lets a man with severe male factor become a father, but the cause of his low count may be genetic. Clinicians therefore consider tests such as a karyotype and Y-chromosome microdeletion analysis in severe oligozoospermia or azoospermia, and cystic fibrosis gene testing when the vas deferens is absent. A Y-chromosome microdeletion can be passed to a son. This counselling is the clinician's task, but you should understand why it matters.
On the day: the laboratory's part
The method is agreed in advance between the clinician and the couple and written in the consent. On the day of pick-up, the laboratory may find that the prepared sample is much poorer than expected, or that sperm cannot be found in an ejaculate at all. You do not change the method yourself. You report the finding at once to the senior embryologist, who speaks with the clinician; any change is documented with the couple's consent before you proceed.
At the bench
- Before the case, read the treatment sheet: method planned, consent signed, any special notes (frozen sperm, surgical sperm, PGT planned).
- After sperm preparation (pages 10 to 13), record the post-wash count and motility on the worksheet.
- Compare the result with the plan. If they disagree, stop and escalate.
- For a split case, label two dishes clearly by method and keep the oocyte allocation on the worksheet.
- Witness every dish identity check as usual (page 3).
Common errors
- Choosing the method from the diagnostic semen analysis alone and ignoring the prepared sample.
- Switching method on the day without the clinician and documented consent.
- Forgetting that warmed oocytes and PGT cases normally need ICSI.
- Muddling oocytes between the two dishes in a split case.
Check yourself
- Which steps of natural fertilisation does ICSI bypass?
- List five accepted indications for ICSI.
- Why is ICSI not used routinely when the semen is normal?
- On the morning of pick-up, the post-wash sample is far poorer than expected. What do you do?
Questions on this page
Is ICSI better than conventional IVF?
Neither is better in general. ICSI is the right method for specific indications such as severe male factor or previous fertilisation failure. When the semen is adequate, conventional insemination is appropriate and less invasive.
Who decides between IVF and ICSI?
The clinician decides with the couple, and the decision is written into the consent. The laboratory reports what it finds on the day and escalates if the sample does not match the plan.
Why are frozen-thawed oocytes injected?
Vitrification can harden the zona pellucida, making natural sperm penetration less reliable, so warmed oocytes are normally inseminated by ICSI. See page 50.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
