Andrology QC and troubleshooting
On this page you will learn
- The difference between internal quality control and external quality assessment
- How replicate counts and observer comparisons keep your results honest
- Which equipment checks the andrology bench needs, and how often
- A step-by-step way to troubleshoot poor motility or low recovery after preparation
Why quality control matters
A semen analysis is used to make decisions about treatment. If two technicians read the same sample and report very different results, the report is not useful. Quality control is the routine work that shows your results are consistent from day to day and close to the true value. The WHO laboratory manual for human semen (6th edition, 2021) gives detailed guidance; your laboratory protocol turns it into daily practice.
Internal quality control
Internal quality control is what you do inside your own laboratory.
- Replicate assessments: concentration and motility are assessed in replicate, and the two readings must agree within the limits the WHO manual sets. If they do not, you repeat with fresh aliquots. This catches poor mixing and counting errors.
- Observer comparison: at intervals, each technician assesses the same samples, slides or recorded videos. Results are plotted so that a person who consistently reads high or low is identified and retrained.
- Control charts: results for stored or reference samples are plotted over time. A drift away from the mean shows a problem before it becomes a mistake.
- Morphology slides: a set of stained reference slides is re-read regularly to keep morphology assessment (page 8) consistent.
External quality assessment
In an external scheme, a provider sends the same material to many laboratories, and each reports its results. You then see how your results compare with the scheme's target values. It is the only way to find a bias that your whole team shares. Treat a poor external result as a learning event: investigate, correct and record.
Equipment and materials
- Microscopes: clean optics, correct phase rings, warmed stage checked with a calibrated thermometer.
- Centrifuge: speed and timer verified at the interval your protocol states, and the rotor balanced every time.
- Pipettes: calibrated, with dates recorded.
- Counting chambers: clean, undamaged and of the correct depth for the method.
- Warm blocks, incubators and refrigerators: temperatures logged daily.
- Media: lot number and expiry recorded for every sample prepared, so any problem can be traced to a batch.
At the bench: troubleshooting
When results go wrong, work from the simple to the complex. Change one thing at a time and write down what you find.
- Poor motility after preparation: check the temperature of the warm block and medium, the time from collection to preparation, the centrifuge speed and duration, and the medium lot. Did the collection container come from an approved stock? Some containers and lubricants harm sperm.
- Low recovery: check the initial sample assessment, the gradient volumes, how the pellet was collected and the resuspension volume. Was swim-up chosen for a sample better suited to a gradient (page 13)?
- Discordant replicate counts: check mixing, chamber loading, chamber depth and the dilution calculation.
- Contamination: check aseptic technique, the expiry of media, and the cleaning log for the hood and centrifuge.
- A pattern across many samples: suspect something shared, such as a medium lot, a piece of equipment or a change in room conditions. Report it to the person responsible for the laboratory the same day.
Write it down
Every non-conformance (anything that did not go to protocol) is recorded with the cause found and the action taken. These records are part of the quality system the ART (Regulation) Act 2021 and ICMR national ART guidelines expect, and they are how the laboratory improves. The IVF laboratory uses the same logic on pages 17 to 20.
Common errors
- Repeating a discordant count from the same aliquot instead of mixing and taking a fresh one
- Changing several things at once while troubleshooting, so the cause is never found
- Treating an external quality result as a pass or fail rather than a source of learning
- Not recording the medium lot number, so a bad batch cannot be traced
Check yourself
- What is the difference between internal quality control and external quality assessment?
- Two replicate counts disagree by more than the allowed limit. What do you do?
- Motility falls sharply after preparation in three samples on the same day. Where do you look first?
- Why must the medium lot number be recorded for every preparation?
Questions on this page
How often should observer comparisons be done?
At the interval your laboratory protocol sets. Regular comparison matters more than any single exercise.
What is a non-conformance?
Any event that did not go according to protocol. It is recorded with the cause found and the action taken, so the laboratory can learn from it.
The Genesis ART Textbook is teaching text for trainees and doctors of the Genesis ART Academy. It is not treatment advice and not a laboratory standard operating procedure; every technique is learned under supervision. Page numbers never change.
