Quality in an IVF centre: clinical and laboratory indicators
On this page you will learn
- What a performance indicator is, and why an IVF centre counts
- The six clinical indicators agreed in the Maribor consensus
- The laboratory indicators of the Vienna consensus, in outline
- How a clinician reads a monthly quality report
- Why these figures stay inside the centre
Counting in order to improve
A performance indicator is a figure a centre tracks to see whether a step of care is working as planned. Live birth is the outcome couples care about, but it arrives months later and depends on many steps at once. So it cannot tell you, this month, which step needs attention. Indicators of each process can.
Source: 2021, ESHRE Clinic PI Working Group (Vlaisavljevic et al.), Human Reproduction Open 2021(3):hoab022 - The Maribor consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of performance indicators for clinical practice in ART
Six clinical indicators
An expert group of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology (ESHRE) agreed six indicators for clinical work in ART. Each points to a decision the doctor owns:
- Cycle cancellation before oocyte pick-up (OPU): response prediction and the choice of plan (pages 44-46).
- Moderate or severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (OHSS): prevention steps and the trigger choice (pages 48 and 60).
- Proportion of mature (MII) oocytes at intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI): the stimulation and the timing of the trigger (page 51).
- Complications after OPU: any complication, other than OHSS, that needs extra medical care or a hospital stay (page 49).
- Clinical pregnancy: the whole chain, read with care for case mix.
- Multiple pregnancy: the number of embryos transferred (page 56).
Source: 2021, ESHRE Clinic PI Working Group (Vlaisavljevic et al.), Human Reproduction Open 2021(3):hoab022 - The Maribor consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of performance indicators for clinical practice in ART
Principles only. Medicines and doses are decided by the treating specialist for each patient; this page explains principles only.
Laboratory indicators, in outline
The Vienna consensus gives the laboratory 19 indicators: 12 key performance indicators, 5 performance indicators and 2 reference indicators. The key ones follow the core work of the laboratory: oocytes damaged at injection, normal fertilisation after IVF and after ICSI, IVF cycles with no fertilisation, cleavage and embryo development, blastocyst development, biopsy success, survival after warming, and implantation.
Source: 2017, ESHRE Special Interest Group of Embryology and Alpha Scientists in Reproductive Medicine, Reproductive BioMedicine Online 35(5):494-510 - The Vienna consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of ART laboratory performance indicators
The two reference indicators describe the oocytes as they arrive, so they mirror the response to stimulation. For each indicator the paper sets a minimum ("competency") value and an aspirational ("benchmark") value. The embryologist uses those values with the centre's own data; this page does not repeat them. You need to know what each indicator means, not how the laboratory scores embryos (page 53).
Source: 2017, ESHRE Special Interest Group of Embryology and Alpha Scientists in Reproductive Medicine, Reproductive BioMedicine Online 35(5):494-510 - The Vienna consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of ART laboratory performance indicators
Reading the monthly report
- Look at the trend over several months, not one month's figure.
- Check the numbers behind each figure; a small caseload swings widely.
- Read the reference indicators first: if fewer mature oocytes arrive, review stimulation and trigger before blaming the laboratory.
- Split by patient group where it helps: age band, IVF or ICSI, fresh or frozen transfer.
- Agree one action with the laboratory, record it, and look at the effect next month.
The Vienna group advises collecting data monthly, or per fixed number of cases where the caseload is small, with about 30 cases as a starting set. Laboratories should respond promptly to unexpected changes. The group also judged that stimulation can affect the whole cycle but is less likely to move any single laboratory indicator.
Source: 2017, ESHRE Special Interest Group of Embryology and Alpha Scientists in Reproductive Medicine, Reproductive BioMedicine Online 35(5):494-510 - The Vienna consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of ART laboratory performance indicators
The clinical indicators move more slowly. The Maribor group suggests working them out every six months or every 100 cycles, whichever comes first, and watching clinical pregnancy and multiple pregnancy more often than that.
Source: 2021, ESHRE Clinic PI Working Group (Vlaisavljevic et al.), Human Reproduction Open 2021(3):hoab022 - The Maribor consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of performance indicators for clinical practice in ART
The lab side
The embryologist brings the laboratory indicators; you bring the clinical ones. Read them together at a joint meeting. A fall in maturity may be a clinical timing problem; a fall in fertilisation with normal maturity points the laboratory to its own checks.
These figures stay inside
Indicators are tools for safer care, not advertising. The ART Act asks a clinic to counsel each couple about the chances of success of its procedures, which is a private conversation about their own case. Public outcome claims are barred by the NMC's 2026 guidelines, so no outcome figures appear on websites, posters or social media.
Source: 18 Dec 2021, Government of India (Act No. 42 of 2021) - The Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 (section 21(c)(i)); 6 Oct 2026, National Medical Commission (Ethics and Medical Registration Board), Public Notice R-13014/01/2024-Ethics - Guidelines on Ethical Advertising and Public Communication by Hospitals/Medical Institutions and Registered Medical Practitioners
At the clinic
On Day OB-7 you read a mock monthly quality report with the faculty. You mark one clinical indicator that needs action and write the question you would ask the laboratory.
Common mistakes
- Reacting to one month's figure from a handful of cycles
- Blaming the laboratory for low maturity without checking trigger timing
- Comparing raw figures across very different patient groups
- Publishing pregnancy percentages to attract patients
Key points
- Indicators track processes; live birth is too slow to steer daily work
- Six clinical indicators: cancellation, OHSS, MII share, OPU complications, clinical pregnancy, multiples
- Vienna: 12 key, 5 performance and 2 reference indicators for the laboratory
- Read trends with the laboratory; act on one thing at a time
- Outcome figures are for internal use and private counselling only
Check yourself
Answer in your head first, then tap a question to see a short answer. Full model answers are in the faculty guidebook.
1. Why is the live birth rate a poor tool for monitoring day-to-day clinical work?
It comes late and depends on many factors at once, so it cannot show quickly which step needs attention; the Maribor group therefore chose process indicators.
2. Name the six clinical indicators of the Maribor consensus.
Cancellation before oocyte pick-up, moderate or severe OHSS, proportion of mature (MII) oocytes at ICSI, complications after pick-up, clinical pregnancy, multiple pregnancy.
3. What do reference indicators in the Vienna consensus describe?
The oocytes arriving in the laboratory; they act as a proxy for the response to stimulation.
4. How often should laboratory indicators be collected?
Ideally monthly, or per fixed number of cases where caseload is small; an initial set of about 30 cases is a guide.
5. The share of mature oocytes falls for two months. What do you check first on the clinical side?
Trigger timing and the patient's trigger instructions, the interval from trigger to pick-up, and the stimulation plans, before assuming a laboratory fault.
6. From page 70: what are the five steps of an audit cycle?
Standard, measure, compare, change, re-measure.
Training note. Training content for registered medical practitioners. Trainees observe all patient care; they do not treat patients during the programme.
Questions on this page
Which clinical indicators does an IVF doctor watch?
Cancellation before pick-up, moderate or severe OHSS, the share of mature oocytes at ICSI, complications after pick-up, clinical pregnancy and multiple pregnancy.
Are these figures shown to the public?
No. They are used inside the centre to improve care; public success-rate claims are barred by the NMC guidelines.
The Genesis Doctors' Textbook is teaching text for registered medical practitioners on the doctor programmes of the Genesis ART Training Academy. It is not treatment advice and gives no medicine doses; trainees observe all patient care, ultrasound scans are watched only (PCPNDT Act), and bench skills are practised under supervision. Page numbers never change.
